Committing suicide by cutting their throat without hesitation marks is a very rare occurrence. It has been reported in both nearhanging and strangulation victims. Johnny the homicidal maniac is one of vasquez first comics, if not the first, and its pretty damn impressive at least visually. Cut throat injuries are found in different circumstances. Diagnosis requires a high index of suspicion, as patients are frequently asymptomatic immediately after the injury. We present two cases of cut throat wounds, one suicide and one homicide, to show the differences between the pattern of wounds. While accidental hanging is rare, and homicidal hanging is even rarer, hanging is the third most common form of suicide and accounts for 16% of all male, and % of all female suicides. Management of suicidal cut throat injuries in a developing. I am feeling a bit confused about what the difference is between someone who is suicidal and someone who is depressed. Additionally, any time an active duty servicemember visits the er they are required to bring a dd form 689 sick slip filled out by unit medical personnel or chain of command, unless the soldier. There were few differentiating points in the targeted are which made this study. Abstract the most commonly used methods for committing suicide in india are hanging, poisoning, burns, jumping from height, drowning, firearm injuries, stab.
What is the difference between suicide and homicide. Difference between suicidal and homicidal cutthroat wounds. Risk assessment of patients with suicidal and homicidal. The forensic pathologists have a challenging and important task when ascertaining the manner of death when cut throats are presented with no proper history or witnesses.
The wound usually begins higher on the neck on the side opposite to where it terminates since the deceased was a right handed person, the suicide cut throat typically started from upper third of the left side of the neck and be ended at a point lower than the. In true homicidesuicides, the primary intent or motive is suicide, and the homicide is secondary, she said. On autopsy examination a single incised cut throat injury of size 17x2 cm was found over anterior part of neck without hesitation cuts. The treating mental health professional uses clinical judgment to determine the best course of action. Whats the difference between depression and suicidal. The management of these injuries requires a multidisciplinary approach.
Accidental,homicidal and suicidal wounds wound medical. Pdf the forensic pathologists have a challenging task during the ascertainment of the manner of death in cut throat injuries when presented. The suicidal cut throat wound is similar to the homicidal cut throat from behind. Situated in the cerebral cortex on the right side are several relays associated with our territory. To do this, the law creates numerous classifications of homicide, because the circumstances surrounding the act of homicide. Or could it just be physically too difficult to inflict enough of. Someone obsessed with homicide suicide or murder etc urban dictionary and our advertising partners set cookies on your computer to improve our site and the advertisements you see. In itself it is a fascinating aspect of biology but this study is.
One significant difference between suicide and selfharm is intent simply put, a suicidal person sees no other way out and wants to end his or her life. An atypical case of suicidal cut throat injury topic of research paper. In case of cut throat injury there is high chance of injury to blood vessels. To distinguish between a homicidal, suicidal and an accidental cutthroat injury may be very unconvincing for a forensic pathologist on a case to case basis 4. At autopsy, a deep, oblique, long incised injury was found on the front of the neck. Each of these relays is activated by specific types of traumat. Suicide and homicide risk management though often useful, unit watch may not always be the best approach. Early and proper management in expert hands can prevent mortality and morbidity. You did not provide details about your life circumstances but i suspect that you are experiencing a great deal of psychological pain and are in a position in which you feel a lack of power. Cutthroat wounds are a wellrecognized method of homicide, are less commonly used in suicides and are rarely accidental. The most important function of the medical examiner in any death investigation is determining the cause, mechanism, and manner of death. Difference between suicidal wounds and homicidal wounds suicidal homicidal direction oblique from below left ear downwards across front of the neck just above adams apple usually horizontal below the adams apple severity usually not so deep and may only involve the trachea, carotid and esophagus usually deep and may cause involvement of. Suicidal ideation is the act of thinking about suicide as an option for solving your problems.
As nouns the difference between suicide and homicide is that suicide is uncountable intentional killing of oneself while homicide is uncountable the killing of one person by another, whether premeditated or unintentional. We highlight the differences between the two cases in relation to other external injuries, the circumstances in which the bodies were found and other factors. Being suicidal is actively planning and executing whatever activity will cause your death. Suicidal cut throats are less commonly reported and accidental cut throats are rare. A heart attack, fall off a ladder, serious kitchen burn or bone break. A lot of will power required to cut deeply into groin or carotid arteries, which are the only ones likely to kill you. The disease or trauma that directly caused the victims death. Homicidal and suicidal sharp force fatalities in stockholm. I have been intrigued by murder and serial killers, it borderlines on obsession. Understanding suicide and selfharm psychology today. Cut throat injuries are a unique form of trauma that is potentially devastating and associated with substantial emotional, physical and financial burden on community and hospital resources. Suicidal ideationhomicidal ideation how is suicidal ideationhomicidal ideation abbreviated. This paper presents our experiences with managing three unemployed adult nigerian males two of hausa ethnicity and one from the tiv ethnic group presenting with cut throat injuries following suicidal attempts. That is what are moral fiber contributes in the differences.
The distinction between homicidal, suicidal and accidental wounding is a central issue in forensic. Suicidal left side of neck, passing across the throat,usu, in rt handed level above thyroid cartilage multiple,superflcial,rarely single edges usually ragged,due to overlapplng hesitation cuts present. Theres a difference in the mindset of a selfharmer and someone who is suicidal. An atypical case of suicidal cut throat injury sciencedirect. Schizophrenia is associated with an increase in the risk of both homicide and suicide. Cut throat injuries causes profound morbidity due to prolonged hospitalization, high cost of health care, loss of productivity and reduced quality of life and above all death 1, 2. Blunt vascular injury is rare but is thought to be one of the most underdiagnosed injuries and may have devastating delayed complications. Suicidal ideationhomicidal ideation listed as sihi. As a verb suicide is to kill oneself intentionally.
There is a range of homicidal thoughts which spans from vague ideas of revenge to detailed and fully formulated plans without the act itself. The other homicidal case involved incised wound on neck by a sharp knife. The forensic pathologist has a very challenging and important task when commenting on the manner of infliction of such wounds when such a case is presented with no proper history or witnesses. The difference between the mindset of a selfharmer and a person contemplating suicide. Provided to youtube by the orchard enterprises homicidal, suicidal outlaw josey scott lil wyte doubt me now. Accidental, suicidal or homicidal injury springerlink. Depth of the incision is more at the commencement while it becomes shallower as it crosses the throat, giving an indication regarding the direction of the slit and the handedness of the victim. Cut throat wounds are a wellrecognized method of homicide, are less commonly used in suicides and are rarely accidental.
The difference between suicide and homicide is that a person commits suicide by killing himself. Throat cuts could be of homicidal, suicidal or accidental origin. Death occurs due to 1 profuse haemorrhage 2 air embolism 3 inhalation of. Both homicidal and suicidal asked by an anonymous user on 2018058 with 1 answer. Synonyms for cutthroat at with free online thesaurus, antonyms, and definitions. The law treats these acts the same in terms of making the acts unlawful. Examples include a heart attack, a gunshot wound to the head, or a. Describe the differences between suicidal and homicidal cut throat 15 2. In the cases of death from cut throat, suicide can be distinguished from homicide based on the type and location of the wound and.
Now, the comics dont actually have an overarching plot, but rather consist of small bits of johnnys life mixed in with some oneortwopage smaller comics. There is a difference between a thought and acting on that thought. Cut throats can be homicidal, suicidal or accidental. Most homicidal cutthroat injuries are inflicted from behind the victim, and the head is pulled back to expose the throat. The forensic pathologist has a very challenging and important task when com. Homicidal ideation is a common medical term for thoughts about homicide. Homicidal cutthroats are a wellrecognized method of killing.
With suicide the intent is to bring end to ones life. Suicidal ideationhomicidal ideation how is suicidal. The wound usually begins higher on the neck on the side opposite to where it terminates 6. Stabbing with needles hatpins, knitting needles, etc. Cutting of the wrist using a sharp object is a more common method of attempting suicide. Suicidal cutthroat injuries were found in 111 61% of 183 sharp force suicides in a series from prussia in 1900. A key factor in providing quality care to members is to keep in. In homicidal attacks, cutthroat injuries and stab wounds to the neck induced by sharp weapons are often life endangering. Cut throat injury is incised injury over the neck, inflicted by sharp elements such as razor, knives, broken bottle pieces, glasses etc, which may be homicidal or suicidal or accidental. A person commits homicide by killing another person. Are homicidal thoughts and anger symptoms of severe. Since the deceased was a right handed person, the suicide cut throat should typically start from upper third of the left side of the neck and be ended at a point lower.
For instance, a woman2 cut the walls of her vagina, and when the intestines protruded she pulled dowzi several feet, and cut them off. Homicidal or aggressive cutthroat injuries can usually be differentiated from suicidal ones by considering the wounds and associated features in context. Emergent, urgent or routine when to visit the emergency. Many people who have homicidal ideation do not commit homicide. Most people who commit suicide by hanging, jump from a chair or a ladder. I understand that someone who is suicidal is wishing for their death sentence, but it truly is a fine line between someone who feels helpless and someone who just doesnt see any way out. One factor to consider is that a unit watch carries some risk of stigmatization by peers. The study of wounds is mainly directed towards relating the tissue and organ changes to the mechanisms of injury and the time of their occurrence. One thing to make clear up front is that this is not typical behavior of someone with depression or suicidal thoughts cornette said her organization estimates that just 2 to 5 percent of suicides are murdersuicides. Most cut injuries to the throat are homicidal than they are suicidal or accidental 23 4. Cut throat injuries at a university teaching hospital in.
Slitting of the throat seems like a more definite and for sure form rather then some of the latter, i know a suicide attempt is a cry for help so could that play a role in it. Should you visit the emergency department, urgent care or. Homicidal cutthroats are a wellrecognized method of killing while suicidal cut throats are less commonly reported and accidental cut throats are rare. Suicidal incised wounds are generally situated on the front of the body in easily accessible positions, especially, on the throat or chest. Risk assessment of patients with suicidal and homicidal ideations dear ubh provider, ubh is committed to working with our providers in a collaborative manner to ensure high quality clinical care for our members.
976 1340 158 836 1260 184 124 1039 778 1635 886 116 1252 1029 1572 791 1378 435 702 1571 1438 1067 67 670 574 1582 542 1237 246 403 1023 389 29 273 1128 40